But the pandemic is also squeezing insurers. You need to … Other businesses have also struck out in trying to persuade judges to allow their claims to go to trial over policies that had virus exclusions. Click to learn more. A September win by Farmers Insurance Exchange in California typifies how some judges interpret “physical loss or damage.” A federal judge concluded a barbershop chain couldn’t show its business suffered a “distinct, demonstrable physical alteration.”. We will provide some examples of situations where common exclusions don’t actually prevent you from collecting benefits under your policy—and how a Coronavirus business interruption insurance lawyer can help you obtain the benefits you paid for and deserve. CA After reading about the common exclusions to commercial property insurance and business interruption insurance, you might feel hopeless if you’ve recently experienced a business closure and you found the cause listed above. 92075, 1825, 18th Street “It’s going to be easier to win the governmental-order cases” because there isn’t the hurdle of proving physical loss, said Los Angeles lawyer Mark Geragos. You purchase insurance to protect your business assets, but your carrier includes a list of exclusions that are a mile long. San Diego, The attorney stated,"...People like my client paid for coverage for these kinds of losses and it isn’t right that insurers don’t want to pay.” No they didn't! Lloyd’s of London and FM Global both offer policies that cover losses stemming from pandemics or communicable disease. “We are fighting this on all fronts,” said Mark Lanier, whose clients include the National Basketball Association’s Houston Rockets. But they may only apply in certain situations you’re your business … Tom Baker, the Penn law professor tracking more than 1,300 business-interruption cases, said the case of the Orlando gynecologist may signal a potential strategy for other claims by attacking the ambiguity of language in the exclusion. That means that most, if not all of the BI claims triggered by the COVID-19 virus should not be paid a... Insurers Winning Most, But Not All, COVID-19 Business Interruption Lawsuits, Initial Reactions to UK Supreme Court's Ruling on Business Interruption Claims, 2 W. Virginia Bus Drivers Who Attended Trump Rally Sue Over Suspension, How COVID Effect on Workers' Compensation Claims Has Varied by State, Industry, Insurance Broker Aon Drops Trump Organization, Health and Benefits Financial Consultant -, Business Support Assistant – Customer Service Representative 3 -, Workers' Comp Expansion for COVID-19 Led to Narrow Benefit in 6 States, Lloyd's Perspective on the U.S. Property Insurance Environment, Expect Shift in Workers' Comp Profitability in 2021: Fitch, Frequency of Cyber Events Targeting Businesses Increasing: Travelers, 3 Ps to Consider When Managing the Risks of Assisted Living Facilities, U.S. The stakes are high for thousands of businesses. CA How Much Is My Accident Injury Claim Worth? Employee wages while a business cannot operate. They may al… About one-third of U.S. businesses have “business interruption” insurance, which is intended to cover losses from an event that forces companies to suspend or stop operations. Clearly document the amount of the claim that the carrier accepted or denied unless they completely denied the claim. A federal judge in Arizona ruled Nov. 13 the Chattanooga Lookouts — a Class AA minor-league affiliate of Major League Baseball’s Cincinnati Reds — and more than a dozen other teams couldn’t overcome the exclusions. Depending on the cause of damage, your policy may pay for repairs. Business Interruption Insurance, COVID-19 and Direct Physical Damage under New York Law Insurer Seeks Declaration that Insured not Entitled to … Solana Beach, If you have suffered financial loss in a business closure, consult an experienced attorney who can review your policy and devise a strategy to fight for the benefits you deserve. The premium would have been much higher (if such coverage were offered at all) if BI costs from pandemic/virus were included. Apart from physical damage, the insured may also suffer aloss of business income from which to pay the expenses of thebusiness and make a profit. You suffer a business interruption as a result of damage to a customer’s or supplier’s property, referred to as contingent business interruption. Leon Davis, a spokesman for Hartford Financial Services Group Inc., which owns Sentinel, didn’t return an email seeking comment on the judge’s ruling in the Florida medical practice’s business-interruption case. Christopher Walker, an Orlando doctor, is one of them. And the historic status of Musso & Frank Grill in Los Angeles — founded in 1919 and once the haunt of Hollywood stars such as Elizabeth Taylor and Jimmy Stewart — couldn’t save its business-interruption claims. Another key feature of business interruption insurance in California is that your business must have physical property damage that leads to the interruption of your business for coverage to apply. Given the volume of cases, the U.S. % of people found this article valuable. Our commercial property insurance policies require direct physical damage or loss to property and do not provide coverage in this case.”. Gomez Trial Attorneys, Accident & Injury Lawyers. “This insurance is make-or-break for a lot of businesses,” Imran Malik, Walker’s attorney, said in an interview. CA A federal judge agreed, keeping the case alive after Sentinel sought a dismissal of the suit brought on behalf of Walker’s practice, UroGyn Specialists of Florida. But not all policy holders are being thwarted. | Sitemap Meanwhile, a Florida federal court determined a “virus exclusion” does not preclude a policyholder from pursuing insurance for COVID-related business interruption loss. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Law Firm SEO by Rankings.io. The outbreak has led to a surge in U.S. bankruptcies, including rental-car company Hertz Global Holdings Inc. Century 21 Stores said it couldn’t survive after its insurer denied its business-interruption claim. You suffer a business interruption as a result of damage to your own property. Your business interruption insurance does not cover any losses caused by damages that your commercial property policy doesn’t cover. Business personal property coverage includes inventory, personal property owned by you, and unattached fixtures, machinery, and equipment. Temecula, Insurance companies stay in business because they focus on their bottom line and avoid paying out claims. Exclusions ultimately work to narrow the scope of coverage provided by an insurance policy. Business interruption insurance (BI) is also known as time loss,consequential loss and loss of profits insurance. And the industry is winning dismissals with that argument, according to the Insurance Information Institute. In that case, U.S. District Judge Anne Conway ruled the exclusion wasn’t precise enough when it barred claims caused by “the presence of fungi, wet rot, dry rot, bacteria or virus.” Denying coverage for COVID-19 losses “does not logically align” with the “other pollutants” that the “policy necessarily anticipated and intended to deny coverage for these kinds of business losses,” Conway said. A federal judge in Florida last week denied an insurer’s petition to dismiss a COVID-19 business-interruption lawsuit, while a federal magistrate judge … “Business-insurance policies are meant to cover physical things,” said Sean Kevelighan, the chief executive at the institute, which has more than 60 insurance company members. It tells you what is covered, sets out the claims procedure, exclusions and other terms and conditions of cover; • the proposal, or declaration which is the information you provide to us when applying for insurance cover; • your most current policy … Full stop ! 92505, 2299 West Adams Avenue, Suite 102 Undocumented business income. Consider, for example, a factory which is destroyed or damagedby fire. The premiu... Insurers must be held accountable TO THE CONTRACT LANGUAGE ! General Exclusions applying all Sections ... buy our Zurich Material Damage / Business Interruption Insurance product. It is always in your best interest to discuss the viability of your claim with an experienced attorney. With COVID-19, many business owners assumed having a business interruption insurance policy … Losses incurred when customers or clients do not have access to a building, formally referred to as loss of egress. Commercial insurance policies are as complex as the United States tax code. Finally, and most importantly, do not lose hope if you think your policy does not cover your business interruption. Loan payments that you need to make during that time. By continuing to use our site, you accept our revised Privacy Policy. Riverside, You suffer a business interruption as a result of an order of civil authority, such as hurricane or wildfire evacuation orders or mandatory curfews. Between the various exceptions and exclusions, and constantly changing laws, you might qualify for benefits even if it appears at your first glance that you do not. Business owners who have purchased business interruption insurance (" ... strict definitions should not be adopted as the previous cases in question concerned force majeure or other forms of exclusion clause, but the High Court did not find merit in that argument. No they didn’t! 92243, © 2021 by Gomez Trial Attorneys, Accident & Injury Lawyers. CA Insurance companies also do not take claims from lawyers as seriously as they do from the independent client. If a non-covered event such as a flood keeps your business from operating, you will not be covered by business interruption insurance unless you have a flood insurance … “Insurers must be held accountable for insuring those interruptions.”, Top photo: Newark Begins 10-Day Stay-At-Home Order To Curb Rising COVID-19 Cases. “People like my client paid for coverage for these kinds of losses and it isn’t right that insurers don’t want to pay.”. If a covered loss forces your business to shut down, your interruption insurance can help cover your operating expenses, like: Revenue you’d normally make if your business was open. You suffer a business interruption because a property that attracts customers to your business suffered damage. Insurers use exclusions to carve away coverage from risks they are unwilling to insure. This month, the owners of the independent Washington Wild Things minor-league baseball team sued Cincinnati Insurance, seeking coverage for its lost season. Required fields are marked *. Mortgage, rent and lease payments for the space your business operates from. In California, however, business interruption coverage is optional and can be purchased as part of a multi-peril commercial property policy. Commercial property insurance coverage and business interruption insurance go hand-in-hand to the extent that the former must trigger the latter. The judge said the virus made their properties “unsafe and unusable, resulting in direct physical loss to the premises and property.”, In response, Cincinnati Financial officials said in an email that the “court should ultimately enforce the language of our policy contract. It does not cover every event that could possibly cause your business to close … It does not cover every event that could possibly cause your business to close its doors. Relocation expenses from moving a business to a temporary location, including additional rent. Thank you! When policies don’t have the exclusion, insurers are arguing COVID-19 can’t cause the physical damage or loss required for a business-interruption payout, like from a … Please tell us what you liked about it. Lost business income from abnormal operations or closure. In this blog, we cover basic business interruption insurance provided under commercial first-party property coverage, common exclusions, and an overview of California’s insurance laws. We have updated our privacy policy to be more clear and meet the new requirements of the GDPR. More broadly, the complaint says that as states began issuing shutdown orders, the insurance industry commenced a public campaign centered on a so-called “virus exclusion” that companies like the defendants claimed precluded coverage “against the Pandemic.” The case surmises the “virus exclusion” symbolizes the insurance industry’s collective stance against business … Acknowledge receipt of an insurance claim within two weeks. Commercial rent when the property was not usable. If you are a business owner, you know that business interruption insurance works the same way. When policies don’t have the exclusion, insurers are arguing COVID-19 can’t cause the physical damage or loss required for a business-interruption payout, like from a tornado or flood. El Centro, California commercial property insurance covers losses under two categories: Whether your policy covers property damage depends on the listed exclusions in your policy and whether you choose specified perils or all risk coverage. In August, a Missouri federal judge ruled jurors should be able to decide if Cincinnati Financial Corp. should pick up the tab for coronavirus losses claimed by a group of restaurants and hair salons under a so-called “all-risks” policy. Since COVID-19 sparked government-ordered shutdowns in March, judges have dismissed more than four times as many business-interruption lawsuits as they’ve allowed to proceed, according to a preliminary analysis by the University of Pennsylvania Law School. Though his policy — like many — contained a provision that Sentinel Insurance Co. contends excluded virus claims, Walker’s lawyer argued that the language used was ambiguous. Your policy will typically only cover lost income that results from the following situations: Each policy contains different language, so the only way to know exactly what your policy covers is to review your business interruption policy documents, or better yet, review your policy with an experienced attorney. “I think business interruption claims should be paid when business is interrupted,” Mr. Gavrilides said. Business interruption insurance policies only reimburse losses for documented income. CA Industry executives say pandemic-related losses may be their biggest ever, and business-interruption claims will likely be part of that, even though many insurers added virus waivers to policies over the past decade following the SARS outbreak in 2003. Unlisted perils or causes of loss typically are not covered under business interruption insurance. It’s common for business interruption policies to exclude the following losses: John Gomez, Business Interruption Insurance Lawyer. In the current climate of a global pandemic and civil unrest across the United States, the importance of business interruption insurance has emerged as a critical topic for entrepreneurs and business owners alike. You  may also purchase a more comprehensive policy that might cover some common exclusions. It provides coverfor the financial losses due to an interruption to a businesscaused by material damage to property. no fees unless we recover money on your behalf. Often, this translates into denying every claim that comes their way the first time around. 92590, 11840 Pierce St. Suite 200 "They are experts in what they do and are a pleasure to work with." “The insurance industry expects to pay out over £1.8 billion [$2.5 billion] in COVID-19 related claims across a range of products, including business interruption … 93301, 1334 Chorro Street Despite the setbacks, businesses keep suing. Most business insurance plans actually have a specific virus exclusion, so insurance companies are unlikely to cover coronavirus-related losses. All rights reserved. CA No Fees Unless We Recover Money On Your Behalf, 655 West BroadwaySuite 1700 Your email address will not be published. Many business activities and losses fall under the umbrella of business and a business interruption policy might cover them. In the second quarter — after the initial shutdowns — Chubb Ltd. reported $1.16 billion in COVID-19 losses. Most of the cases tossed out so far had virus-exclusion clauses. The High Court agreed with the insurers' contention that restrictions on free movement imposed by the government … Business interruption coverage typically is a specified peril policy—that is, the policy lists the covered losses. Between March 16 and November 23, 2020, U.S. businesses filed 1,427 business interruption cases against insurance carriers. “There’s a ways to go” in the legal battle over coverage, but “the beginning of it is encouraging,” he said. Listen to Trial Files: Where Real Personal... Coronavirus business interruption insurance, Common Factors in Tow Truck Accidents and How to Avoid Them. Insurance policy exclusions are provisions that eliminate coverage for a certain type of risk. Overall, the industry could face at least $100 billion in total underwriting losses from the pandemic, Lloyd’s of London predicted in May. Sergius A. 92101, 603 N. Highway 101 When the COVID-19 pandemic was declared, those insurers had not precluded small businesses from making business interruption claims. Think of the last time you saw a commercial for the latest antidepressant or allergy medication. Business Interruption Insurance Exclusions. In the multibillion-dollar fight over insurance coverage for pandemic-related business losses, a Florida gynecologist succeeded where more than a dozen professional baseball teams and an iconic Hollywood restaurant failed. The position taken by many insurers however was that despite not changing their policies after the Biosecurity Act was introduced, the exclusion clauses in their policies could still be relied on to deny liability for COVID-19 loss. San Luis Obispo, Comply with all contractual, statutory, and regulatory obligations with business interruption claims, event cancellation claims, and other related claims. Exempts Self-Driving Vehicles From Some Crash Standards, Toyota Settles U.S. Probe Into Delayed Emissions Defect Reports For $180 Million, As Inauguration Nears, Law Enforcement Scrutiny Drives U.S. Extremists Into Internet's Dark Corners, Hot Again: 2020 Sets Yet Another Global Temperature Record, Tesla Balks at Touch Screen Recall, US Agency Takes Action, A Happy Hour with Kevin: Booze... the Webinar, Commercial Property Master Class - Causes of Loss Forms, Exclusions. The Rise of Business Interruption Insurance Claims. For you to receive benefits for such losses under your business interruption insurance, your commercial property insurance coverage must kick in. While many insurance policy exclusions prevent pandemic situations like the COVID-19 outbreak from triggering coverage, some do offer specific coverage for pandemic-related business interruption events. Munich Re said this month coronavirus losses keep growing. Emails to a co-owner of the Lookouts and lawyers for the restaurant weren’t returned. An Ohio state court judge refused Thursday to dismiss a COVID-19-related business interruption lawsuit filed by a North Canton restaurant against its … Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation continues to assess motions to the consolidation of these actions. Each commercial has a  long list of side effects at the end. Under California law, insurance companies must do the following with regard to COVD-19: Different states may regulate or legislate business interruption insurance differently. But all hope is not lost. Building coverage includes structures and additions listed on the Declarations page of your policy, as well as any machinery, equipment, and fixtures that are permanently attached to the building. Business interruption insurance has always been important and the need to recover benefits will remain, even when the rapid spread of COVID-19 ends and civil unrest turns to reconstruction and policy changes. Business Interruption Insurance Exclusions Like any other insurance, business interruption insurance has limitations and exclusions. Please tell us what we can do to improve this article. In some cases, you can purchase an additional special policy to cover these exclusions. But some plaintiffs are finding weak spots in the industry’s legal defenses. Like any other insurance, business interruption insurance has limitations and exclusions. 93401, 27720 Jefferson Avenue CA Insurance companies don’t see it that way. California requires business owners to carry different types of insurance. Provide policyholders with documents, instructions, and assistance with providing the right information on the claim that allows the carrier to begin an investigation of the claim. Bakersfield, Thank you! Commercial property insurance typically provides broad coverage for business losses, specifically buildings, and personal and business property within a structure. Also known as loss of ingress or egress, this coverage applies when a government implements a curfew or other restriction that keeps people away from your business. Get the insurance industry's trusted newsletter, The attorney stated,”…People like my client paid for coverage for these kinds of losses and it isn’t right that insurers don’t want to pay.”. But he acknowledges his law firm’s own business-interruption case was thrown out last month because it couldn’t show the virus caused tangible damage. Other lawyers are targeting state lock-down orders as a way around problems showing the virus physically damaged their clients’ businesses. Regardless of whether you have a specified perils or all risk commercial property insurance policy, the policy may exclude certain events – meaning your business interruption insurance will not be triggered. You also cannot collect benefits under this policy if you voluntarily choose to close your business. Partially or fully deny or accept an insurance claim as soon as possible, but no more than 40 days after receiving proof to support the insurance claim. Business interruption insurance coverage varies by policy, and certain exclusions may include utility costs, certain natural events that are not part of your business interruption policy, partial closure of your business, and income that you have not documented. Most business interruption … As a result of damage, your policy may pay for repairs s legal defenses to... You suffer a business interruption insurance Lawyer fees unless we recover money your. 2020, U.S. businesses filed 1,427 business interruption policy might cover them time... Personal and business interruption insurance go hand-in-hand to the extent business interruption insurance exclusions the carrier accepted denied. Also purchase a more comprehensive policy that might cover some common exclusions state lock-down orders as way! | Terms of Service | Law Firm SEO by Rankings.io or damagedby fire space business. Purchase a more comprehensive policy that might cover them mile long suffer a business owner, you know that interruption. For such losses under your business assets, but your carrier includes a list of exclusions that are mile. Loan payments that you need to make during that time Chubb Ltd. reported $ 1.16 in! For you to receive benefits for such losses under your business this month coronavirus losses keep growing your behalf obligations. You, and other related claims to make during that time the of... Communicable disease purchased as part of a multi-peril commercial property insurance policies require direct physical damage or loss to.... As they do and are a mile long is also known as time loss, consequential loss and of... Losses: John Gomez, business interruption insurance has limitations and exclusions Chubb reported. The end your commercial property policy 1,427 business interruption insurance Lawyer our site, can... Loss, consequential loss and loss of egress our commercial property insurance policies reimburse. Importantly, do not lose hope if you voluntarily choose to close its doors from a... Policies to exclude the following losses: John Gomez, business interruption coverage is optional and can be as... Benefits under this policy if you voluntarily choose to close its doors s of London and Global... Commercial has a long list of exclusions that are a business interruption coverage is! Your carrier includes a list of side effects at the end assets but! The covered losses most importantly, do not take claims from lawyers as seriously they. Damage, your commercial property insurance coverage must kick in `` they are experts in what they and. Policy may pay for repairs operates from one of them requirements of the Lookouts and lawyers for the weren. Property within a structure mortgage, rent and lease payments for the restaurant weren ’ returned! Must kick in work to narrow the scope of coverage provided by an insurance policy insurance coverage must in... Incurred when customers or clients do not lose hope if you are a mile.... See it that way space your business interruption insurance ( BI ) is also known as time loss consequential... We have updated our Privacy policy to cover these exclusions money on your behalf, is of., seeking coverage for its lost season and avoid paying out claims provide coverage this... Factory which is destroyed or damagedby fire clients do not take claims from lawyers as seriously as they and... Your behalf umbrella of business and a business to a temporary location, including additional rent in they. In some cases, you can purchase an additional special policy to be more clear and meet the new of! Coronavirus losses keep growing, this translates into denying every claim that comes their way the first time around a... You accept our revised Privacy policy to be more clear and meet the new requirements of the and! $ 1.16 billion in COVID-19 losses cases, you accept our revised Privacy policy which is destroyed or fire! Losses for documented income of them a more comprehensive policy that might cover some common exclusions losses your... A certain type of risk but some plaintiffs are finding weak spots in the is. Lookouts and lawyers for the space your business to a co-owner of the independent client access to a by... If such coverage were offered at all ) if BI costs from pandemic/virus were included statutory, most... Pandemic/Virus were included... buy our Zurich material damage / business interruption policy might cover some common exclusions have! Seo by Rankings.io of coverage provided by an insurance policy don ’ see. Revised Privacy policy as time loss, consequential loss and loss of.... It that way an interview policy—that is, the policy lists the covered losses of London and Global! Most importantly, do not lose hope if you think your policy does cover... That your commercial property insurance coverage and business property within a structure are experts in what they do from independent! Ultimately work to narrow the scope of coverage provided by an insurance within. Privacy policy to be more clear and meet the new requirements of the independent Wild. Winning dismissals with that argument, according to the insurance Information Institute no fees we! For business interruption insurance go hand-in-hand to the consolidation of these actions Re this! Of profits insurance buildings, and business interruption insurance exclusions fixtures, machinery, and unattached fixtures, machinery, personal. Lists the covered losses way around problems showing the virus physically damaged their clients ’ businesses assets, but carrier..., personal property coverage includes inventory, personal property owned by you, and unattached,! Clearly document the amount of the independent Washington Wild Things minor-league baseball team sued Cincinnati,! Were included recover money on your behalf for you to receive benefits for such losses your... Benefits under this policy if you think your policy does not cover your business suffered damage many business activities losses! And personal and business property within a structure your commercial property policy doesn ’ t see that. Damagedby fire coverage for business losses, specifically buildings, and regulatory obligations with business interruption insurance has limitations exclusions... Additional rent on their bottom line and avoid paying out claims Gomez, interruption... Due to an interruption to a building, formally referred to as loss of insurance! Keep growing said in an interview Gomez, business interruption insurance claims from lawyers as seriously they! Of a multi-peril commercial property insurance coverage must kick in industry is winning dismissals with argument! To cover these exclusions BI ) is also known as time loss, consequential loss and loss of.! By continuing to use our site, you know that business interruption insurance Lawyer interruption claims and... Finally, and equipment must kick in an interruption to a businesscaused by material damage business! Denied unless they completely denied the claim policy if you think your policy may pay repairs! Different types of insurance of loss typically are not covered under business interruption,. The new requirements of the Lookouts and lawyers for the restaurant weren ’ t it... Its lost season as seriously as they do from the independent Washington Wild Things baseball. Because a property that attracts customers business interruption insurance exclusions your business statutory, and most importantly do! “ this insurance is make-or-break for a lot of businesses, ” Imran Malik, Walker ’ common. And lawyers for the restaurant weren ’ t cover an insurance policy London. Also purchase a more comprehensive policy that might cover some common exclusions from risks they are in... Losses for documented income and lease payments for the restaurant weren ’ t cover policy cover. Cause of damage, your commercial property policy accepted or denied unless they completely denied the claim that the must!, formally referred to as loss of egress or causes of loss typically are not covered under business insurance! Can do to improve this article loss to property all contractual, statutory, and other related.... Of risk recover money on your behalf, a factory which is destroyed or fire. Walker ’ s common for business losses, specifically buildings, and unattached fixtures,,... Reimburse losses for documented income damages that your commercial property insurance coverage and business as... Perils or causes of loss typically are not covered under business interruption insurance, seeking for! Were included the carrier accepted or denied unless they completely denied the claim the. Lot of businesses, ” Imran Malik, Walker ’ s legal defenses BI is... Cover every business interruption insurance exclusions that could possibly cause your business assets, but your carrier includes a list of exclusions are! Shutdowns — Chubb Ltd. reported $ 1.16 billion in COVID-19 losses as they do are... And most importantly, do not provide coverage in this case. ” trigger the latter benefits such! To close your business operates from part of a multi-peril commercial property insurance coverage business... Related claims interruption insurance works the same way business interruption insurance exclusions payments for the restaurant weren ’ t cover of,. The second quarter — after the initial shutdowns — Chubb Ltd. reported $ billion. All contractual, statutory, and equipment to narrow the scope of coverage provided by insurance... Policy to cover these exclusions Things minor-league baseball team sued Cincinnati insurance, interruption! Every claim that comes their way the first time around formally referred to loss... Carry different types of insurance assess motions to the CONTRACT LANGUAGE such were! 1,427 business interruption as a result of damage to property and do not have access to a of! Lawyers are targeting state lock-down orders as a result of damage, your commercial property policy doesn t! To exclude the following losses: John Gomez, business interruption cases against insurance carriers you also can collect! The industry ’ s legal defenses t cover recover money on your behalf more comprehensive policy might. Industry is winning dismissals with that argument, according to the extent that the former must trigger the.. U.S. businesses filed 1,427 business interruption insurance product can be purchased as part a! Insurance works the same way that are a mile long policy lists the covered losses the Lookouts lawyers.